THEY RECORDED A SECRET SECOND “HIGHWAYMAN”-TYPE SONG THAT MOST PEOPLE NEVER TALK ABOUT — “AMERICAN REMAINS.” Everybody remembers “Highwayman.” That is the song that gave the group its myth, its title, its afterlife. But five years later, The Highwaymen recorded something that almost feels like a hidden sequel. On Highwayman 2 in 1990, they cut “American Remains,” a Rivers Rutherford song that Johnny Cash’s official site lists on the album, and Rolling Stone later noted that it was Rutherford’s first major cut. It is another multi-character song, another piece built for several voices, another attempt to hold different American lives inside one performance. But instead of becoming immortal in the culture the way “Highwayman” did, it slipped into the shadows A group this mythic did not just have one defining song and then stop. They tried to do it again. They reached for another sweeping American story. And the song most people forgot became, for Rivers Rutherford, the breakthrough that opened his whole career.
“Scroll down to the end of the article to listen to music.” They Did Not Stop After “Highwayman.” They Tried…